Noted Attorney says Shugy’s letter of resignation is a done deal
By Aabigayle McIntosh
Another member of the legal fraternity is weighing in on the matter surrounding the resignation of St Mary’s South Member of Parliament Kelvin “Shugy” Simon, saying it is a done deal.
This is despite the determination by Speaker of the House Sir Gerald Watt that Simon failed to meet the criteria as established by the Constitution and therefore it is ‘Constitutionally deficient, a nullity and of no legal effect’.
He also stated that Simon would have to submit a second letter following certain provisions including disassociating himself from the party that he is associated with.
US-based Attorney-at-Law Beverly Benjamin George insisted that the Constitution of Antigua and Barbuda is very clear on the issue of resignation and as far as she is concerned the matter is a done deal.
“My resignation is effective once I give it to you. It does not say anything about you receiving it, it does not say anything about you rejecting it, it does not say anything about you opining on it. It says once you receive it’s done,” George said during a radio interview.
She also stressed that the country’s constitution does not indicate one giving a reason for submitting a letter of resignation.
“I did get a copy of the Speaker’s letter and I noticed that it made reference to section 41 1 (A). I just can’t imagine that the speaker would make a comment or a reference that seems to have no connection to the situation,”
Section 41 of the constitution, the lawyer said is entitled tenure of seats of members of the house.
Tenure is the period with which something is held, George said.
She said that particular section is defining the period that a member of the House, holds on to the seat and when they do not.
That section reads” Every member of the House shall vacate his, seat in the House-. at the next dissolution of Parliament after he has been elected; i. if he ceases to be a citizen; ii. if he is absent from the sittings of the House for such period or periods and in such circumstances as may be prescribed in the rules of procedure of the House; iii. subject to the provisions of subsection (2) of this section, if any circumstances arise that, if he were not a member of the House, would cause him to be disqualified from election as such by virtue of section 39(1) of this Constitution; or iv. if, having been elected to the House by virtue of being a member of a political party, he resigns his party whip and withdraws his allegiance from that party”.
“The speaker is someone who has been around for a very long time, he is very experienced and I don’t think he would just issue excited utterances. We have to lift the hood and really look clearly to determine his true intentions,” George continued.
She was also asked directly whether the Speaker has any authority to accept or reject a resignation to which she replied “No”.
Asked what should be Simon’s next step she stated, “There is nothing for him to do just tell the speaker to have a nice day and keep it moving”.
This story was first published by Antigua News on : antigua.news/2023/06/14/noted-attorney-says-shugys-letter-of-resignation-is-a-done-deal. © 2023 Antigua News. Republication without permission is not allowed.

About the author
The Editorial Staff refers to all reporters employed by Antigua.news. When an article is not an original creation of Antigua.news—such as when it is based on a press release, other media articles, letters to the editor, or court decisions—one of our staff members is responsible for overseeing its publication.
Read our editorial standards and corrections policy. Spotted an error? Contact the newsroom.
More from Antigua and Barbuda
View section
ABEC Chairman Arthur Thomas Completes OAS Electoral Training Programme in Washington
The five-day programme brought together electoral officials from across the Americas to strengthen election observation, electoral security and public confidence in democratic processes.
By Cory Wayland
Minister Rawdon Turner Rejects Claims of Restricted Public Access to Jolly Beach
The Social and Urban Transformation Minister says public access remains open, the walking distance has been reduced and the government plans to establish a dedicated beachfront park.
By Cory Wayland
Illegal Guns Fueling Violence Across Caribbean as Criminal Networks Grow More Sophisticated
Suriname's Justice and Security Minister warns that illegal firearms trafficking is becoming increasingly difficult to combat, urging CARICOM countries to strengthen border security, intelligence-sharing and regional cooperation.
By Cory Wayland
Antiguans Warned of Possible Fuel Price Increases Despite Falling Global Oil Prices
Government spokesman Maurice Merchant says continued instability in the Middle East could force higher prices at the pumps, even as international crude oil benchmarks record another weekly decline.
By Cory Wayland
Comments (1)
Mae June 14, 2023, 11:32 AM