Dorian Marshall Walks Free as Court of Appeal Quashes Murder Conviction
By Cory Wayland
The Court of Appeal has overturned a murder conviction and 40-year prison sentence, ruling that Dorian Marshall should not face retrial for the killing of Xavier Thomas.
Marshall’s conviction for Thomas’ murder on August 18, 2017, was quashed by the appellate court, which determined that flaws existed in the prosecution’s case against him.
In their judgment delivered Thursday, the three Justices of Appeal criticized the quality of evidence presented during the original trial.
The court stated that “the quality of the identification evidence was poor, and since there was no other evidence which supported its correctness, the learned trial judge…ought to have withdrawn the case from the jury at the end of the case for the prosecution and direct an acquittal.”
The original murder case involved three defendants, with Marshall being the only one convicted by the jury. The other two co-defendants saw no verdicts reached in their cases.
The appellate proceedings took place last October, with the court’s decision announced several months later. Marshall’s legal team consisted of attorneys Wendel Alexander and Wayne Marsh, while the Crown’s case was presented by Shannon Jones Gittens.
The Court of Appeal’s ruling not only reversed Marshall’s conviction and sentence but also explicitly prohibited any future prosecution attempts in connection with Thomas’ death, effectively closing the case against him.
This story was first published by Antigua News on July 10, 2025: antigua.news/2025/07/10/dorian-marshall-walks-free-as-court-of-appeal-quashes-murder-conviction. © 2025 Antigua News. Republication without permission is not allowed.
About the author
Cory Wayland is the Social Media Co-ordinator at Antigua.News, where he manages digital content strategy, audience engagement, and real-time news publications across social platforms. With a keen eye for trending topics and a commitment to factual storytelling, Cory plays a key role in shaping the online voice of Antigua.News.
Read our editorial standards and corrections policy. Spotted an error? Contact the newsroom.
More from Antigua and Barbuda
View section
Hundreds Caught In Miles-Long Gas Lines As Dealers Protest Increased Margins
Motorists are scrambling for fuel as leading service stations shut their pumps for the second time in weeks, while WIOC’s Friars Hill station reportedly remains the only WIOC location still dispensing gasoline.
By Cory Wayland
Four-Country CARICOM Free Movement Scheme Reports 939 Processed as Antigua Maintains Separate Conditions for TCN Transfers
Antigua and Barbuda remains outside the four-country scheme, while proposing strict limits and safeguards for temporary transfers of third-country nationals from the US.
By Shermain Bique-Charles
Elderly Man Found Dead Inside Ovals Home
Police are investigating after an elderly man was discovered unresponsive at his home in Ovals on Wednesday morning, with no indication of foul play at this stage.
By Cory Wayland
WATCH: Taxi Operators Call for Proper Policing as Minister Freeland Reviews Concerns in St. John’s
Taxi association representatives say vehicles occupying designated spaces and soliciting cruise passengers are affecting operations around Heritage Quay.
By Shermain Bique-Charles
Comments (10)
Donna July 10, 2025, 3:19 PM
Stone July 10, 2025, 3:27 PM
Jermimah July 10, 2025, 4:02 PM
Juju Bee July 10, 2025, 7:24 PM
informed Citizen July 10, 2025, 7:28 PM
Drink wata July 10, 2025, 11:07 PM
Rhea July 11, 2025, 1:34 AM
Raheem July 11, 2025, 2:56 AM
Ben Simmons July 11, 2025, 1:31 PM
Sheesh July 14, 2025, 1:05 PM