The Pope, The President, and Peter Tosh | Why the Caribbean Must Choose Justice Over False Peace

Published
The Pope, The President, and Peter Tosh | Why the Caribbean must choose justice over false peace

By Professor C. Justin Robinson
Pro Vice-Chancellor and Principal, The UWI Five Islands Campus

Everyone is crying out for peace, yes,
None is crying out for justice.
Everybody want to go to heaven,
But nobody want to die.

 Peter Tosh, Equal Rights (1977)

That warning, from half a century ago, frames everything that follows.

When Pope Leo XIV warned that nations arming themselves before negotiating are preparing for a greater war, Washington called him disgraceful. The Pope spoke of justice, Washington spoke of strength. Between them stands the ghost of Peter Tosh, who understood, before either of them spoke, that dominance is not peace, surrender is not peace, both are war paused, waiting for the next generation to inherit the bill.

Washington offers domination, silence imposed by the stronger. The Pope, like Tosh, demands justice, the costly, disruptive, unglamorous work without which no ceasefire holds. The Caribbean has lived under both and we must choose.

Consider the Strait of Hormuz, thirty-three kilometres wide with twenty percent of the world’s traded oil passing through it. A closure leads to a spike in energy prices that can break the most vulnerable economies first. The Caribbean imports nearly all its fuel; our tourism, our aviation, our food chains are acutely price‑sensitive and structurally exposed.

Lloyd Best taught us to read this exposure as architecture, not accident, when he said the plantation economy did not end, it adapted. Our vulnerability to a closure ten thousand kilometres away is the inheritance of an economy organized, from its origins, for someone else’s account.

The U.S.–Israel confrontation with Iran, now in its seventh week with talks stalled, is not distant drama. We are not watching this war; we are inside it. Economic exposure does not automatically confer moral authority. But silence in the face of structurally determined vulnerability is not neutrality, it is acquiescence. Our exposure is not incidental, as Lloyd Best taught us it is the design of an economy we did not author. Gaza, Sudan, Ukraine, these are not separate tragedies, they are the same tragedy recurring, and the recurrence has a structure.

The world is offered, again and again, not peace but two kinds of silence. The first is dominance where the stronger party takes enough that resistance becomes impossible. The bombed are not at peace, they are exhausted. The second is surrender where the weaker party signs unjust terms because it can no longer afford to refuse. Both are called peace, neither is.

The Treaty of Versailles punished Germany without addressing the war’s causes, and twenty years later the world burned again. The Oslo Accords, as critics have long argued, tried to build a Palestinian state on paper while leaving the occupation intact; today, Gaza is rubble. The Taif Agreement ended Lebanon’s civil war by redistributing power among the same factions that produced it and the country has lurched from crisis to collapse ever since.

This pattern is not coincidence, it is arithmetic. Injustice deferred is war with interest, and the interest compounds with each generation. Peace is what we say we want, but justice is what we keep refusing to pay for. The bill always comes due, and it is rarely paid by those who incurred it.

For the Caribbean, this is memory, not theory. The plantation was peaceful, in that sense. Colonial order was peaceful, in that sense. The silence of the dispossessed has been called peace in this region many times, and we know exactly what it cost. We, of all people, have no excuse for mistaking managed injustice for peace.

But Tosh understood something harder still. In that same song he offered another observation, sharp as a blade: “Everyone wants to go to heaven, but nobody wants to die.” We want the arrival without the passage; Easter Sunday without Good Friday. We want peace, most of us genuinely do, but we flinch from the hard, disruptive, costly work of justice on which lasting peace depends. Justice is Good Friday work. It demands discomfort, sacrifice, the willingness to disturb arrangements from which we quietly benefit. So, we settle, repeatedly, for the peace of dominance and the peace of surrender, because they are cheaper in the short run. We keep choosing the interval, and we keep inheriting the next war.

So here is Tosh’s question, the one the song was really asking: Do we want peace because we believe in justice, or because war is inconvenient? Do we recoil from Gaza because our conscience is troubled, or because the oil price spike hurts our hotels? Are we crying out for peace, or for the return of our comforts?

Washington’s answer is on the record, with surrender and dominance driven ceasefire resolutions and massive military buildups. The Pope has been dismissed as disgraceful for insisting that justice precedes peace. The Pope’s answer is equally clear; peace is the work of justice. But Tosh’s answer remains the fullest, equal rights and justice for everyone, not only for those whose suffering is convenient to notice.

And so, the Caribbean must speak, not through communiqués alone, but through the voice of its people. To say “the Caribbean” is not to pretend we are of one mind. It is to insist that our shared exposure demands a shared voice even where unity is hard. We have done this before. On climate justice, we refused the terms of those who caused the damage. We named the injustice before asking for the remedy. That same moral architecture is required now, applied to war, occupation, and the selective enforcement of international law.

The Caribbean people must demand three things. First, that any ceasefire be judged not by the silence it produces, but by whether accountability is binding for all parties and not suspended the moment the violator is an ally. Second, that reconstruction never be used as leverage for silence: no rebuilding without rights. Third, that amnesty never come before truth. Justice deferred is the next war scheduled.

This voice will cost us. It will cost diplomatic capital and the comfortable neutrality some seek at this cruel and dangerous moment, the quiet approval of powers whose favour we have learned to cultivate, sometimes against our own interest. But the alternative, crying out for peace while endorsing the structures that guarantee its failure is precisely what gave us Gaza, Sudan, and a closed Strait.

It has never worked, it cannot work, it is not designed to. Might is not right, and peace built on it is always temporary and always someone else’s burden when it breaks.

If the Strait stays closed, oil spikes further and air travel becomes unaffordable, no one will airlift us to safety. We will bear it, as we have borne every cost not of our making. So let us at least stand for something that outlasts the bearing.

“I don’t want no peace,”  Tosh sang. “I need equal rights and justice.”  Washington calls the Pope disgraceful. Tosh, from his grave, calls them both to account. The Caribbean people have always known which voice echoes from the marrow of our history. The question is whether we will sing it again loud enough, in time, and not as petitioners, but as free people naming justice on our own terms.

This story was first published by Antigua News on : antigua.news/2026/05/06/the-pope-the-president-and-peter-tosh-why-the-caribbean-must-choose-justice-over-false-peace. © 2026 Antigua News. Republication without permission is not allowed.

Step 1

Add Antigua.news to your Home Screen

✕ antigua.news ⋯ Open in Safari Copy link Share…

First, open this page in Safari

You are reading inside another app (Instagram, Facebook…). Tap ⋯ at the top right and choose Open in Safari (or Open in browser).

No such option? Copy the link, open Safari and paste it in the address bar.

⚙️ Settings General › Software Update

Update your iPhone first

Alerts need iOS 16.4 or newer. Open Settings → General → Software Update and install the update. You can still add the icon now: tap Next.

‹ antigua.news ⋯

Tap the ⋯ button

It is at the bottom right of Safari, next to the address bar. Don't see the bar? Scroll up a little.

Share Add Bookmark New Tab Find on Page

Tap Share

It is the first option of the menu, with a square-and-arrow icon.

antigua.news ‹ › ▢ ⧉

Tap the Share button

The square with an arrow pointing up, in the middle of the bar at the bottom (on iPad: at the top right).

antigua.news

Tap the Share button

The square with an arrow, at the right of the address bar at the top. (Firefox: tap ☰ at the bottom, then Share.)

Copy Add to Reading List Add to Home Screen

Tap Add to Home Screen

Scroll down the list to find it (icon: a square with a +). Not there? Tap Edit Actions or View More at the bottom.

Cancel Add to Home Screen Add Antigua.news Open as Web App

Keep Open as Web App on, then tap Add

The switch must be green — without it, alerts can't work. Then tap Add at the top right.

Cancel Add to Home Screen Add Antigua.news An icon will be added to your Home Screen so you can quickly access this website.

Tap Add

At the top right. If you see an Open as Web App switch, leave it on (green).

Antigua.news

Close the browser and open Antigua.news from its new icon

Go to your Home Screen: the Antigua.news icon is there now (swipe left if you don't see it). Alerts only work when you open us from this icon.

“Antigua.news” Would Like to Send You Notifications Notifications may include alerts, sounds and icon badges. Don’t Allow Allow

Tap 🔔 Turn on alerts, then Allow

In the app you will see a red box asking to turn on alerts: choose your sections, tap the button, then tap Allow. That's it — breaking news will reach you even with the phone locked.

Editorial Staff

About the author

The Editorial Staff refers to all reporters employed by Antigua.news. When an article is not an original creation of Antigua.news—such as when it is based on a press release, other media articles, letters to the editor, or court decisions—one of our staff members is responsible for overseeing its publication.

Read our editorial standards and corrections policy. Spotted an error? Contact the newsroom.

Comments (2)

  • Informed citizen May 6, 2026, 4:25 PM

    Caribbean people cyah keep quiet pon injustice and call dat peace. Real peace come when people treated fair.
    Reply
    • Apex Jones May 7, 2026, 4:48 PM

      Amen to that. Couldn’t have said it better even if I tried
      Reply

Submit a comment

More from Antigua and Barbuda

View section