Accident Investigation reports critical safety risks not understood by crew on striken yacht that claimed life of Antiguan citizen
UK investigators found that the Bayesian’s crew were unaware of the yacht’s vulnerability to extreme winds before it capsized off Sicily, killing seven people, including Antiguan chef Recaldo Thomas.
By Mick the Ram
The UK's Marine Accident Investigation Branch (MAIB) have concluded that the crew of the Bayesian superyacht which sank off the coast of northern Sicilly just over two years ago, were unaware that the 56-metre (184ft) luxury vessel had vulnerabilities to extreme weather.
Seven people tragically died when a sudden and violent downburst of freak hurricane-force winds knocked the yacht onto its side in less than 15 seconds on 19 August 2024. Recaldo Thomas, an Antiguan citizen, who was working as the Bayesian's on-board chef, was one of those who was killed along with British tech tycoon Mike Lynch, 59, his 18-year-old daughter Hannah, and married couples: Jonathan and Judy Bloomer, andChris and Neda Morvillo.
Mr Thomas had heartbreakingly told a friend back in Antigua that he “was really tired” and would only need to work for two more seasons, so he could “fix up his late parents’ house.” Friends spoke of how kind and well-loved he was by everybody and how he had become an inspiration to young black children who wanted to get into yachting.
James Cutfield, the ship’s captain; Matthew Griffith, a deckhand; and Tim Parker Eaton, the chief engineer, are all currently under investigation in Italy over possible multiple manslaughter charges, as well as culpable shipwreck.
During the early hours of the morning, with the Bayesian anchored outside of Porticello port, the report confirmed that wind speeds rose from 8 knots to about 70 knots (80mph) within a matter of minutes, even though the forecast had only predicted gusts of up to 27 knots (31mph).
The terrible accident developed with extraordinary speed and MAIB principal inspector Simon Graves said in the comprehensive report: “It was very dynamic, the speed of events overtook the crew and prevented them from taking any other action.”
The marine investigation found that the craft had never been “assessed at anchor with its sails down” and said that the “extreme winds that night were not explicitly forecast”, meaning that the crew had no warning of any risk.
It also found that any knockdown - where the boat suddenly lurched sideways - would be “irrecoverable once the yacht passed the angle of vanishing stability” assessed in the study as being 73 degrees. Once beyond this angle it could never right itself. Additionally, the centreboard, which would have provided stability, had been raised.
The MAIB's final report into the sinking actually contradicts recent reports from Italy, where prosecution experts who are leading a parallel criminal investigation, have reportedly blamed errors by the crew rather than problems with the superyacht itself. However, this is possibly due to the fact that Italian prosecutors had restricted access to some witnesses and evidence.
This story was first published by Antigua News on : antigua.news/2026/11/19/accident-investigation-reports-critical-safety-risks-not-understood-by-crew-on-striken-yacht-that-claimed-life-of. © 2026 Antigua News. Republication without permission is not allowed.

About the author
Mick Burrows is an independent freelance author based in the UK, boasting over 20 years of experience in the online writing landscape. His extensive background has enabled him to develop a diverse range of material, marked by a unique and distinct style. Recognized as a platinum-level expert author by leading e-zine publications, Mick excels in optimizing content for Search Engine Optimization (SEO) through effective keyword density and distribution. He has served as the lead reviewer for a travel enterprise and the senior previewer at a sports prediction company, melding his passions for sport—particularly football and cricket—with his love for travel, having explored more than 50 countries worldwide.
Read our editorial standards and corrections policy. Spotted an error? Contact the newsroom.
More from Antigua and Barbuda
View section
Antigua and Barbuda Joins Caribbean Push for More Reliable Diagnostic Imaging
A three-member delegation attended a workshop in The Bahamas on reducing equipment downtime, training specialists and keeping diagnostic imaging and radiation medicine services safe and accessible.
By Shermain Bique-Charles
Antigua and Barbuda Launches Water-Saving Irrigation Training for 81 Participants
The 28-day programme will teach farmers, backyard gardeners and agricultural technicians how to use drip irrigation and monitor soil moisture as the country grapples with drought.
By Shermain Bique-Charles
After 40 Years in Food Business, Susan Shaw Gets EC$50,000 Boost to Expand With Food Truck
The owner of Rite Yah So Chill Spot will use a low-interest entrepreneurial loan to take her catering services to events across the country.
By Cory Wayland
Rendezvous Bay Development Proposal Sets Aside More Than 80 Percent of Estate for Nature
Elmsbridge outlines a 330-acre luxury residential project with habitat restoration, a public beach park and projected economic benefits.
By Cory Wayland
Comments
Be the first to comment.