A Garden Fence, Ten Years in Court and a £1 Million Legal Bill

A 95-year-old woman won damages against her neighbours but failed to recover the wider costs of a boundary dispute. The courts called the result a draw.

Published
Editorial illustration of a small garden fence between English country houses beside a towering stack of legal papers.
Editorial illustration of a garden boundary dispute and mounting legal costs. The properties depicted are imaginary. · Editorial illustration for Antigua.news

Over ten years, a garden fence dispute between neighbours in the English village of Sissinghurst acquired enough fences to need a numbering system. There was Fence 1, Fence 2 and Fence 3. Then evidence of an earlier fence emerged at trial, requiring the introduction of Fence 0.

The bills were less complicated. Mary Egan, 95, says she has spent more than £1 million on the litigation. Her neighbours, Neil and Fiona Morgan, have spent a six-figure sum, despite representing themselves for much of it.

On November 16, the High Court rejected Mrs Egan’s appeal over who should bear the costs. The courts had already awarded her damages for trespass. They had also refused important parts of what she wanted. After a decade of proceedings, the official assessment remained a “score draw”.

The disputed land covers about 45 square metres along a boundary roughly 60 metres long. Mr Justice Tappin described its practical or other value as extremely limited, if it had any at all. The legal costs had found considerably more room to grow.

How the Kent boundary dispute began

The dispute developed in 2015 around the hedge separating the Morgans’ garden from Mrs Egan’s field. The Morgans put in posts and replaced an existing fence. Mrs Egan objected to the position of the replacement and removed it. The Morgans then erected another fence, this time with concrete posts.

They sued in 2016 over the fence she had taken down. She counterclaimed, seeking a ruling on the boundary, compensation for trespass and an order removing the latest fence.

This was the difficulty with treating it as a simple argument about broken fencing. Mrs Egan maintained that the boundary ran through the middle of the hedge. Where that line fell would determine who controlled the land, the trees and the placement of the barrier.

Then a witness supplied evidence about an older fence. Its line lay a few inches west of Fence 1, but east of the hedge. Neither side had advanced it as the true boundary.

In his 2022 judgment, the trial judge, Recorder Dagnall, accepted that earlier line. Parts of the Morgans’ fences had encroached on Mrs Egan’s land. He rejected their claim for damages and awarded her £1,300 for trespass, plus £1,300 in aggravated damages.

But he declined to order the removal of Fence 3. Instead, he awarded another £3,250 and declared that the line of Fence 3 was to become the boundary. Mrs Egan had established wrongdoing and been awarded £5,850. She had not secured the boundary she had argued for, or the removal she had sought.

Those distinctions became expensive.

Why the £1 million costs appeal failed

Mrs Egan’s argument on costs had an obvious attraction: the Morgans had lost their damages claim; she had won hers; they were the people required to pay. Why should she carry the legal bill?

The answer turned on what the litigation had actually been about. Money was only part of the requested outcome. Keeping the boundary out of the hedge and avoiding an order to remove the fence mattered to the Morgans. The judge was entitled to count those results, too.

That was the reasoning behind leaving each side broadly responsible for its own costs. There were limited exceptions, including a requirement that the Morgans pay one-third of Mrs Egan’s costs of attending a hearing in November 2017.

The million-pound figure is her account of her own expenditure. This month’s decision did not impose a fresh £1 million penalty or award that sum to her neighbours. It left her attempt to recover the wider bill unsuccessful.

She also argued that Mr Morgan’s conduct justified making the couple pay. The proceedings had generated a vocabulary considerably less restrained than the judgment.

In court papers cited at the appeal, he was said to have described a judge as “not fit to judge vegetables at a village fete”. Lawyers and Mrs Egan also received personal insults. The local produce competition had somehow become a benchmark of judicial competence.

Mr Morgan’s position was that the couple had been provoked and that the occasions when he responded were being used against them. The High Court condemned abusive language towards lawyers, judges and court staff. It nevertheless found no error that justified overturning the trial judge’s assessment of costs.

An appeal on costs did not give either side a fresh opportunity to have the whole quarrel weighed from the beginning. The appeal court could not substitute its preference simply because another judge might have divided the bill differently.

The main judgment had run to 88 pages. A further decision on consequential issues added another 38. This month’s appeal concerned the bill for reaching those conclusions.

Under the orders now in place, the boundary follows the line of Fence 3. Neither side has been declared the overall winner. Both have had ample opportunity to calculate what that distinction costs.

This story was first published by Antigua News on : antigua.news/2026/11/21/garden-fence-dispute-million-pound-legal-bill. © 2026 Antigua News. Republication without permission is not allowed.

Step 1

Add Antigua.news to your Home Screen

✕ antigua.news ⋯ Open in Safari Copy link Share…

First, open this page in Safari

You are reading inside another app (Instagram, Facebook…). Tap ⋯ at the top right and choose Open in Safari (or Open in browser).

No such option? Copy the link, open Safari and paste it in the address bar.

⚙️ Settings General › Software Update

Update your iPhone first

Alerts need iOS 16.4 or newer. Open Settings → General → Software Update and install the update. You can still add the icon now: tap Next.

‹ antigua.news ⋯

Tap the ⋯ button

It is at the bottom right of Safari, next to the address bar. Don't see the bar? Scroll up a little.

Share Add Bookmark New Tab Find on Page

Tap Share

It is the first option of the menu, with a square-and-arrow icon.

antigua.news ‹ › ▢ ⧉

Tap the Share button

The square with an arrow pointing up, in the middle of the bar at the bottom (on iPad: at the top right).

antigua.news

Tap the Share button

The square with an arrow, at the right of the address bar at the top. (Firefox: tap ☰ at the bottom, then Share.)

Copy Add to Reading List Add to Home Screen

Tap Add to Home Screen

Scroll down the list to find it (icon: a square with a +). Not there? Tap Edit Actions or View More at the bottom.

Cancel Add to Home Screen Add Antigua.news Open as Web App

Keep Open as Web App on, then tap Add

The switch must be green — without it, alerts can't work. Then tap Add at the top right.

Cancel Add to Home Screen Add Antigua.news An icon will be added to your Home Screen so you can quickly access this website.

Tap Add

At the top right. If you see an Open as Web App switch, leave it on (green).

Antigua.news

Close the browser and open Antigua.news from its new icon

Go to your Home Screen: the Antigua.news icon is there now (swipe left if you don't see it). Alerts only work when you open us from this icon.

“Antigua.news” Would Like to Send You Notifications Notifications may include alerts, sounds and icon badges. Don’t Allow Allow

Tap 🔔 Turn on alerts, then Allow

In the app you will see a red box asking to turn on alerts: choose your sections, tap the button, then tap Allow. That's it — breaking news will reach you even with the phone locked.

Dario Item

About the author

Dr. Dario Item is the Head of Mission of the Embassy of Antigua and Barbuda in Madrid. He is an experienced financial crimes lawyer with nearly 30 years of practice. He holds degrees in law and political science, a Ph.D. in criminal law and an LL.M. in transnational financial crime.

Read our editorial standards and corrections policy. Spotted an error? Contact the newsroom.

Comments

Be the first to comment.

Submit a comment

More from Style

View section