Jury Deadlocked 5–4 in Rape Trial Involving 14-Year-Old Girl, Accused Faces Retrial
After more than five hours of deliberations, jurors failed to reach a verdict in the week-long High Court trial, where defence attorneys challenged inconsistencies in the evidence and the handling of the police investigation.
By Cory Wayland
A 28-year-old man accused of raping his teenage cousin will face another trial next year after a nine-member jury failed to reach a verdict following more than five hours of deliberations in the High Court on Friday.
The jury remained divided five to four at the conclusion of the week-long proceedings before Justice John Spencer, bringing the trial to an end without a conviction or acquittal.
The accused, who was 26 at the time of the alleged incident, is charged with raping his cousin on December 5, 2024, when she was 14 years old.
The prosecution alleged that the assault occurred inside the defendant's bedroom at his home, located a short distance from the complainant's residence in the same yard.
During the trial, the teenager testified that her cousin had asked her to iron one of his shirts and that the alleged assault occurred as she was unplugging the iron.
Her mother also gave evidence about learning of the alleged incident while heading towards the defendant's house.
The court heard that the mother subsequently confronted the accused and struck him with a frying pan.
Throughout the proceedings, the defence challenged the reliability of the prosecution's case, drawing attention to what attorneys described as significant contradictions between the complainant's initial police statement and her testimony in court.
Defence attorneys Wendel Alexander and Wayne Benjamin Marsh argued that the inconsistencies raised serious questions about the evidence presented against their client.
They also strongly criticised the police investigation, questioning why investigators had not visited the alleged crime scene despite the incident reportedly occurring during the day while family members were at home.
Another issue raised by the defence concerned the handling of potential forensic evidence.
The court heard that swabs had been taken from the accused and that the complainant's underwear had been handed over to police on the day of the alleged incident.
However, according to the defence's arguments, no forensic examinations were conducted on those items.
Alexander and Marsh characterised the investigation as seriously inadequate, using the term “kangaroo” to describe what they considered shortcomings in the police's handling of the allegations.
The defence maintained that the combination of inconsistencies in the complainant's accounts and the absence of forensic testing undermined the prosecution's case.
The accused maintained his innocence, delivering an unsworn statement during the trial in which he denied the allegation.
Prosecutor Akilah Southwell presented the Crown's case during the proceedings, which continued throughout the week.
Following the presentation of evidence and closing arguments, the nine-member jury retired to consider its verdict.
However, after approximately five and a half hours of deliberations, jurors were unable to reach the required agreement, remaining split five to four.
The deadlock resulted in a hung jury, meaning the case concluded without a determination of the accused man's guilt or innocence.
The matter is now expected to return to the High Court for retrial during next year's criminal assizes.
The accused remains entitled to the presumption of innocence unless and until proven guilty in court.
This story was first published by Antigua News on : antigua.news/2026/11/21/jury-deadlocked-5-4-in-rape-trial-involving-14-year-old-girl-accused-faces-retrial. © 2026 Antigua News. Republication without permission is not allowed.

About the author
Cory Wayland is the Social Media Co-ordinator at Antigua.News, where he manages digital content strategy, audience engagement, and real-time news publications across social platforms. With a keen eye for trending topics and a commitment to factual storytelling, Cory plays a key role in shaping the online voice of Antigua.News.
Read our editorial standards and corrections policy. Spotted an error? Contact the newsroom.
More from Antigua and Barbuda
View section
ABEC Chairman Arthur Thomas Completes OAS Electoral Training Programme in Washington
The five-day programme brought together electoral officials from across the Americas to strengthen election observation, electoral security and public confidence in democratic processes.
By Cory Wayland
Minister Rawdon Turner Rejects Claims of Restricted Public Access to Jolly Beach
The Social and Urban Transformation Minister says public access remains open, the walking distance has been reduced and the government plans to establish a dedicated beachfront park.
By Cory Wayland
Illegal Guns Fueling Violence Across Caribbean as Criminal Networks Grow More Sophisticated
Suriname's Justice and Security Minister warns that illegal firearms trafficking is becoming increasingly difficult to combat, urging CARICOM countries to strengthen border security, intelligence-sharing and regional cooperation.
By Cory Wayland
Antiguans Warned of Possible Fuel Price Increases Despite Falling Global Oil Prices
Government spokesman Maurice Merchant says continued instability in the Middle East could force higher prices at the pumps, even as international crude oil benchmarks record another weekly decline.
By Cory Wayland
Comments (1)
Unfiltered View November 21, 2026, 1:17 PM
It’s disappointing that a case involving such a young girl has ended without a verdict. At the same time, the justice system must ensure that every aspect of the evidence and investigation is properly examined. Hopefully, the retrial will bring clarity and accountability, and most importantly, that the young girl receives the justice and support she deserves.
Reply